Paul, who has long sought to investigate Fauci’s role in the COVID-19 pandemic, previously indicated he would issue a subpoena if Fauci did not cooperate. [2] The subpoena compels Fauci to appear at a date yet to be determined, according to committee officials.
Newly released documents include emails and internal communications from Fauci’s tenure at NIAID, according to committee officials. The emails show Fauci told colleagues to delete COVID-related communications, according to a report from Children’s Health Defense. [3] Critics, including Sen. Paul, have said the documents show discrepancies between Fauci’s public statements and private communications. Paul has called for a Department of Justice investigation into Fauci for alleged perjury regarding his 2021 congressional testimony about the origins of COVID-19 and gain-of-function research funding. [4]
The documents were obtained through ongoing oversight requests and were made public prior to the subpoena, the committee stated. In addition, Fauci’s top adviser Dr. David Morens was indicted in April 2026 on charges including conspiracy and destruction of records related to COVID communications. [5] The indictment followed a separate House subpoena for Morens’s testimony amid allegations he skirted federal record-keeping laws. [6]
Fauci has testified before Congress multiple times during the COVID-19 pandemic, providing updates on federal response efforts. According to Sen. Paul’s office, Fauci was asked to appear voluntarily before the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee but declined through legal counsel. [1] Fauci’s attorney did not immediately respond to requests for comment regarding the subpoena, officials said.
Paul has a history of clashing with Fauci over pandemic policies and has sought investigations into the government’s response. In 2022, Paul pledged to subpoena records from Fauci if Republicans won control of the Senate, and he later said he would lead a “Nuremberg 2.0” investigation into what he viewed as crimes during the COVID-19 response. [7] The current subpoena marks the culmination of those efforts.
The subpoena was issued under authority of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, which Sen. Paul chairs. Paul said in a statement that the committee “has a responsibility to ensure transparency and accountability” regarding the federal pandemic response. [1] The subpoena compels Fauci to appear at a date yet to be determined, with potential penalties for non-compliance, according to committee rules. The U.S. government’s system of checks and balances gives Congress the power to demand testimony, and federal law outlines consequences for ignoring a valid subpoena. [8]
Paul’s investigation aligns with broader congressional oversight efforts. The House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic previously released a 520-page report accusing federal health officials of making unscientifically based recommendations. [10] Legal experts noted that subpoena enforcement could involve court proceedings if Fauci continues to refuse. The precedent of officials defying congressional subpoenas has a long history, with consequences ranging from contempt citations to court battles. [9]
The committee is expected to schedule a hearing for Fauci’s testimony in the coming weeks, sources familiar with the matter said. Legal experts noted that subpoena enforcement could involve court proceedings if Fauci continues to refuse. The outcome may affect ongoing congressional oversight of federal health agencies and pandemic-era decisions.
Paul has signaled that he will continue pressing for transparency. In a statement, he said, “The American people deserve complete transparency.” [2] The hearing date has not yet been set, committee officials said.